I liked When Black Birds Fly, Girl In Woods and DickShark.

Here's the ones I have seen.
Volumes of Blood- 7/10 Nice indie anthologie movie.
Hunters- 6/10 Pretty extreme.
Night of Something Strange-7/10 Gross and Weird. But I had fun with it. Even though I almost got sick during some scenes.
Knucklebones- 7/10 Fun slasher. It rip offs scenes from other slashers, but I still like it.
Harvest Lake- 6.5/10 Sexual Creature Feature. The Creature isn't that great, but it's an indie film and I still liked it quite a lot.
The Barn- 8.5/10 It's a fun indie 80s throwback.
Jack Goes Home- 6/10 Strange movie, but has some good acting.
Fender Bender- 8/10 Love this slasher! And on the Blu-ray you can watch it in a converted VHS format.
The Watcher- 6.5/10 Decent thriller.
Abattoir- 6.5/10
Phantasm: Ravager- 6/10
Carnage Park- 7.10
Sacrifice- 6/10 Decent thriller with some horror elements
The Disappointments Room- 3/10 Boring
Love Witch- I'm watching this one today.

Here's the ones I want to see.
February
The Neighbor
Eyes of My Mother
Incarnate
Don't Hang Up
They're Watching
Satanic
Shelley
Frankenstein Created Bikers
Plank Face
Don't Fuck in the Woods
CarousHELL
Lung II
Late Night Double Feature
Minutes Past Midnight
Child Eater
2 Jennifer
Field Freak
We are the Flesh
Don't Kill It
ClownTown
Scare Campaign
Fear Inc.
Sadako v Kayako
Raw
Trash Fire
Beyond the Gates
The Windmill
Antibirth
Siren
The Greasy Strangler
Viral

I'm shocked when I noticed that Kate Beckinsale is in The Disappointments Room. She was an amazing in Blood Wars.

Fender Bender looks awesome, added to my list!

I really want to watch The Barn, how did you get it?

It was actually a birthday present from my brother. He ordered it off https://www.thebarnmerch.com/ . But on the site it says they are trying to get a wide release this year. I'm sure it will be cheaper then. I think you can also rent it somewhere.

The ones I liked:

The Greasy Strangler
The Neon Demon
The Love Witch
SiREN
Beyond The Gates
Attack of the Lederhosen Zombies
Knucklebones
KILD TV
February
The Windmill


The ones I thought were meh (Wouldn't say I disliked them, but left me underwhelmed):

Phantasm Ravager
The Barn
ClownTown
Satanic
All Girls Weekend
They're Watching
Smothered
Chupacabra Territory
The Remains

I haven't seen much at all yet so can't contribute. Will use this for recs though. Here is all I have seen for horror from 2016.

Phantasm Ravager 6.5/10
The Conjuring 2 5.5/10
The Shallows 3.5/10