Let's see here....

2010
The Dead - 5/10
Trollhunter - 6/10
Frozen - 7/10
Devil - 7/10
Beyond the Black Rainbow - 1/10
Insidious - 6/10
Predators - 6/10
Paranormal Activity 2 - 7/10
The Crazies - 6/10

I would still like to see:
I Saw the Devil - 10/10
Rubber - 6/10
A Serbian Film - 6/10

2011
Grave Encounters - 7/10
Inbred - 5/10
The Skin I Live In - 9/10
The Innkeepers - 5/10
You're Next - 9/10
Paranormal Activity 3 - 7/10
Absentia - 8/10

I would still like to see:
Juan of the Dead - 6/10
Kill List - 3/10

2012 - Solid year
The Bay - 6/10
The Conspiracy - 7/10
Inhuman Resources - 7/10
Grabbers - 6/10
Sinister - 6/10
Cockneys vs Zombies - 4/10
Paranormal Activity 4 - 6/10
The ABCs of Death - 6/10
Resolution - 7/10
V/H/S - 7/10

I would still like to see:
The Battery - 8/10
Maniac - 7/10
Excision - 10/10

2013
World War Z - 6/10
Contracted - 9/10
Oculus - 6/10
Under the Skin - 5/10
A Field in England - 5/10
Devil's Pass - 7/10
V/H/S/2 - 8/10
The Sacrament - 8/10
Almost Human - 7/10
Dark Skies - 6/10
The Conjuring - 5/10
Coherence - 9/10

I would still like to see:
Witching and Bitching - 7/10
Wer - 6/10
The Purge - 4/10

2014
Spring - 7/10
What We Do in the Shadows - 8/10
Housebound - 6/10
Unfriended - 7/10
Digging Up the Marrow - 8/10
Life After Beth - 6/10
It Follows - 9/10
Last Shift - 6/10
As Above, So Below - 8/10
Annabelle - 4/10
The Babadook - 5/10
Creep - 8/10
Starry Eyes - 9/10

I would still like to see:
Goodnight Mommy - 9/10
Dead Snow 2: Red vs. Dead - 7/10
Wyrmwood: Road of the Dead - 5/10
Late Phases - 6/10
Tusk - 7/10

2015
Hell House LLC - 7/10
We Are Still Here - 9/10
Baskin - 6/10
Darling - 5/10
Contracted: Phase II - 7/10
The Visit - 8/10
The Devil's Candy - 7/10
Green Room - 5/10
Bone Tomahawk - 9/10
A Christmas Horror Story - 6/10
Bloodsucking Bastards - 7/10
Tales of Halloween - 6/10
They Look Like People - 6/10
The Witch - 3/10
The Invitation - 7/10
The Blackcoat's Daughter - 1/10
Southbound - 8/10

I would still like to see:
He Never Died - 8/10
Krampus - 6/10
Circle - 7/10
Maggie - 5/10
The Boy - 8/10
Deathgasm - 7/10
Howl - 7/10
Knock Knock - 8/10

2016 - Good year for horror
Train to Busan - 6/10
Raw - 8/10
Better Watch Out - 10/10
The Autopsy of Jane Doe - 9/10
Split - 6/10
The Void - 6/10
Hush - 6/10
Don't Breathe - 7/10
The Conjuring 2 - 6/10
The Belko Experiment - 7/10
The Boy - 7/10
10 Cloverfield Lane - 8/10
I Am Not a Serial Killer - 7/10
The Eyes of My Mother - 7/10

I would still like to see:
Beyond the Gates - 6/10
Holidays - 6/10 (10/10 for the segments Easter and Father's Day)

2017
Mother! - 8/10
The Babysitter - 6/10
Creep 2 - 8/10
1922 - 6/10
Gerald's Game - 6/10
The Endless - 6/10
Happy Death Day - 6/10
Get Out - 7/10
The Ritual - 7/10
XX - 5/10
It Comes at Night - 4/10
Jigsaw - 5/10
It - 7/10
Revenge - 7/10

I would still like to see:
Leatherface - 6/10
Cult of Chucky - 8/10
Death Note - 6/10
Jeepers Creepers III - 5/10
47 Metres Down - 5/10

2018
The House That Jack Built - 8/10
Hereditary - 9/10
Bird Box - 8/10
Halloween - 5/10
Unsane - 7/10
A Quiet Place - 5/10
Incident in a Ghostland - 7/10


I would still like to see:
Mandy - 4/10
Summer of '84 - 9/10
The Meg - 6/10

2019
I haven't seen anything from 2019 yet, but I am looking forward to
Velvet Buzzsaw - 4/10
Us - 7/10

Everything else I've rated above a 6:

2010:
Piranha - 7/10
My Soul to Take - 8/10
I Spit on Your Grave - 8/10
All About Evil - 7/10
Tucker and Dale vs Evil - 8/10
The Man Who Collected Food - 7/10
Blood Junkie - 7/10
I Didn't Come Here to Die - 7/10
The Last Circus - 7/10
A Horrible Way to Die - 7/10

2011:
Megan is Missing - 7/10
The Cabin in the Woods - 7/10
The Human Centipede II (Full Sequence) - 7/10
Chop - 10/10
Some Guy Who Kills People - 7/10
Final Destination 5 - 7/10
Hobo With a Shotgun - 8/10
The Taint - 8/10
The Woman - 8/10
Father's Day - 10/10
Chromeskull: Laid to Rest 2 - 7/10

2012:
Mold! - 9/10
Eddie: The Sleepwalking Cannibal - 8/10
The Collection - 7/10
No One Lives - 8/10
John Dies at the End - 7/10
Hellbenders - 7/10
American Mary - 7/10
Chained - 7/10
Would You Rather - 9/10
Here Comes the Devil - 7/10
Stitches - 7/10
Found - 9/10
Daddy's Little Girl - 8/10
100 Bloody Acres - 9/10
Dead Sushi - 8/10

2013:
Evil Dead - 7/10
Texas Chainsaw - 8/10
Motivational Growth - 10/10
Wolf Creek 2 - 8/10
Cottage Country - 8/10
Escape from Tomorrow - 8/10
Mortal Remains - 7/10
Curse of Chucky - 7/10
Bad Milo - 8/10
Return to Nuke 'Em High Volume 1 - 7/10
Blood Glacier - 7/10
Big Bad Wolves - 9/10
Hell Baby - 7/10
Beneath - 7/10
Cheap Thrills - 10/10
The Green Inferno - 7/10
Dry Bones - 8/10
Babysitter Massacre - 7/10
Jug Face - 7/10
Truth or Dare - 9/10
Hi-8 (Horror Independent 8) - 7/10
Willow Creek - 7/10
WNUF Halloween Special - 7/10
Skinless - 9/10
Hotel Inferno - 9/10

2014:
Dark House - 7/10
The Voices - 8/10
Clown - 7/10
Honky Holocaust - 7/10
Bag Boy Lover Boy - 7/10
Girl House - 7/10
Buzzard - 9/10
Call Girl of Cthulhu - 7/10
Zombeavers - 8/10
Blood Punch - 8/10
Fear Town, USA - 8/10
The Guest - 10/10
Eat - 8/10
The Editor - 7/10
Shock Value - 9/10
Summer of Blood - 7/10
Teenage Slumber Party Nightmare - 7/10

2015:
Bound to Vengeance - 7/10
Scouts Guide to the Zombie Apocalypse - 7/10
Freaks of Nature - 7/10
The Final Girls - 7/10
Landmine Goes Click - 7/10
The Hallow - 7/10
Deep Dark - 7/10
Lumberjack Man - 7/10
My Bloody Banjo - 7/10
Stung - 7/10
Killer Rack - 8/10
Lost After Dark - 7/10
Goddess of Love - 7/10
Turbo Kid - 8/10
The Slashening - 7/10
Headless - 9/10
Even Lambs Have Teeth - 7/10
Crush the Skull - 9/10
Alone in the Ghost House - 8/10
Cat Sick Blues - 7/10
Massage Parlor of Death - 7/10

2016:
The Good Neighbor - 8/10
Dolly Deadly - 8/10
They're Watching - 7/10
Night of Something Strange - 8/10
Found Footage 3D - 7/10
Fear, Inc. - 7/10
Don't Hang Up - 7/10
Late Night Double Feature - 7/10
Terrifier - 8/10
The Greasy Strangler - 8/10
Scare Campaign - 7/10
SiREN - 8/10
She Kills - 10/10
Are We Not Cats - 7/10

2017:
Return to Return to Nuke 'Em High Aka Vol. 2 - 9/10
Dead Body - 8/10
Mayhem - 7/10
Mercy Christmas - 7/10
M.F.A. - 8/10
Downrange - 7/10
Who's Watching Oliver - 7/10
Fake Blood - 8/10
Dead Shack - 7/10
One Cut of the Dead - 7/10
The Strangers: Prey at Night - 8/10
Greta - 7/10

2018:
Puppet Master: The Littlest Reich - 7/10
The Witch in the Window - 8/10
Johnny Gruesome - 7/10
The Ranger - 7/10
Leprechaun Returns - 7/10

2019:
The Prodigy - 7/10

By "I", I mean gymno. I copied and pasted his list, and left in all the ones I've seen and rated them.