There are quite a few movies I like on Snowy's list but there are also a few movies I don't like all that much (Scream 4?!) and honestly there are way too many movies from the past decade for my tastes (only 5 movies from the 20th century).

There are quite a few movies I haven't seen on Johan's list and probably don't have much intention to but 1, 2 and 8 are three of my favourite horror movies, 3 is one of the better horror movies of recent years and I enjoyed 6 more than I thought i would. 10 and 12 are also very decent movies.

There is nothing I can say I don't like on Johan's list that I've seen and there are more critically acclaimed movies , therefore I give the edge to Johan.

Johan by a hair. I almost went with Snowy but changed my decision at the last moment. I think some stuff like Scream 4, The Final Girls and Happy Death Day brought her list down.

I'm not big on some of the old crusty B&W's on Johan's list but I respect them more. And he has FleshEater (1988) which rocks.

I have only seen a few off of Johan's list, but I did enjoy A Quiet Place and Carrie. On Snowy's list I know almost all of them. She does have The Devil's Rejects which is one of my favorites, also A Nightmare On Elm Street.

My vote: Snowy

I'll go with Snowy on this one, mostly because there are more that I'm familiar with on that list. Johan's list has some gold on there, but a few I haven't seen.

I got to go with Snowy_Owl even though there is too much newer stuff for my liking, there is more there that I like.

Snowy_Owl

1. A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984) - 10/10
2. A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors (1987) - 8/10
3. Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me (1992) - 6/10
4. Trick 'r Treat (2007) - 6/10
5. Halloween (1978) - 6/10
6. Happy Death Day (2017) - 5/10
7. It Follows (2014) - 9/10
8. The Devil's Rejects (2005) - 8/10
9. It: Chapter 1 (2017) - 7/10
10. The Frighteners (1996) - 7/10
11. The Final Girls (2015) - 7/10
12. Scream 4 (2011) - 6/10
13. Ready or Not (2019) - 6/10
14. Doctor Sleep (2019) - 8/10
15. Terrifier (2016) - 8/10

TOTAL AVERAGE = 7.13/10


Johan_WoW

1. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920) - 6/10
2. Carrie (1976) - 8/10
3. A Quiet Place (2018) - 5/10
4. Blood Feast 2: All U can Eat (2002) - 7/10
5. Trauma (2017) - 6/10
6. Dolls (1987) - 7/10
7. Frankenhooker (1990) - 7/10
8. The Invisible Man (1933) - 8/10
9. The Tingler (1959) - 7/10
10. Black Sunday (1960) - 6/10
11. Cat People (1942) - 6/10
12. Alice, Sweet Alice (1976) - 6/10
13. Spider Baby (1967) - 8/10
14. Yummy (2019) - ?
15. FleashEater (1988) - 7/10

TOTAL AVERAGE = 6.714285/10



SNOWY_OWL

I gotta go with Johan on this one. I like the movies on Snowy's list that I have seen, but I haven't seen them all. I know more of Johan's movies, and I like them all a lot. Way to go, Johan, sticking Dolls in there! Always a classic.

Snowy has some great movies on her list like Nightmare on Elm Street 1 and 3, Fire Walk with Me, Trick 'r Treat, Halloween, The Devil's Rejects, and It. I haven't seen Ready or Not or Doctor Sleep though and I don't like Scream 4.

Johan also has great moves. Carrie, Blood Feast 2, The Invisible Man, Alice, Sweet Alice, Spider Baby. I wouldn't call them great, but I also enjoy Frankenhooker and FleshEater. I haven't seen Trauma or Yummy though and I don't like A Quiet Place or Dolls.

By a small margin, my vote goes to Snowy.