I haven't seen that many of Gymno's movies but knowing his taste they are probably not my taste.

Bambi's list has a few I really do not like at all: The wicker man, the babadook, hereditary.
However it feels a lot fresher than Gymno's pretty dry list (Hellraiser 2 being the exception). On the other hand I don't see any standouts in her list either.


So Bambi

Bambi's list is a right mixed bag but it still has more films I like on it.

Man Bites Dog is not really a horror movie and probably should not have been allowed but my vote still goes to:

Bambi.

Well I don't really find Man bites Dog horror either it's drama/crime/mockumentary. It was drafted last year on the Dutch movie board otherwise I probably would not have watched it. There is a few shocks but for the horror fan there is nothing to get worried about IMO.

While I agree its not really a horror, more crime in hindsight ..

I think the purpose of the challenge is to have fun thou.. we all remember what these challenges were like with Der..

Well it's a bit ironical that I still needed his list to make the KO phase work. But at least he didn't manage to spoil the fun this time.

Bambithedeer

1. Candyman (1992) - 6/10
2. Midsommar (2019) - 8/10
3. Killer Klowns from outer space (1988) - 7/10
4. My Bloody Valentine (1981) - 6/10
5. Sleepaway Camp II (1988) - 7/10
6. The Wicker Man (1973) - 6/10
7. Scream (1996) - 6/10
8. The Babadook (2014) - 5/10
9. The silence of the lambs (1991) - 10/10
10. Black Christmas (1974) - 7/10
11. Beetlejuice (1988) - 6/10
12. They Live (1988) - 7/10
13. Hereditary (2018) - 9/10
14. Happy Death Day 2u (2019) - 5/10
15. Behind the mask: The rise of Leslie Vernon (2006) - 8/10

TOTAL AVERAGE = 6.86/10


Gymnopedie

1. The Addiction (1995) - 4/10
2. Martin (1977) - 5/10
3. Spring (2014) - 7/10
4. The Ninth Configuration (1980) - 5/10
5. Messiah of Evil (1973) - 4/10
6. Hellbound: Hellraiser II (1988) - 9/10
7. I Zombie: The Chronicles of Pain (1998) - 5/10
8. Sole Survivor (1984) - 7/10
9. Tetsuo: The Iron Man (1989) - 5/10
10. The Mothman Prophecies (2002) - 7/10
11. Terrified (2017) - 6/10
12. Circle (2015) - 7/10
13. Man Bites Dog (1992) - 6/10
14. Ju-on (2000) - 4/10
15. Anatomy (2000) - 6/10

TOTAL AVERAGE = 5.8/10



BAMBITHEDEER

Bambi. She just has more films I like.

I have seen all but two movies on Bambi's list, and love them all. Gymno's movies sound interesting, but I haven't seen any of them.

So my vote goes to: Bambi

Gymno definitely has the more interesting list. Spring, The Ninth Configuration, Messiah of Evil, and Hellraiser II are good. Bambi on the other hand has Candyman, Killer Klowns, My Bloody Valentine, Sleepaway Camp II, The Babadook, Black Christmas, Beetlejuice, They Live, Hereditary, Behind the Mask... obviously I'm voting Bambi.

Gymno has some good ones, but I'm a lame bastard and don't know many on his list. I know all of Bambi's list. But Gymno's list has Martin, Spring, and Ninth Configuration, which make for a strong argument...

Sorry Gymno, but I vote Bambi.

OK, this one makes me think it over at least a little, but I definitely have to award Bambi my much-coveted vote. I have seen almost all the movies she posted, and I liked all the ones I have seen, a lot. Gymno gets points though, especially for Mothman Prophecies and The Ninth Configuration.