Bought:

Ice Cream Man (1995)

Outside of the challenge, watched:

Born in East L.A. (1987) (FTV)
Dawn of the Dead (2004)
Megan Is Missing (2011) (FTV)
Uncle Buck (1989)
Dollman (1991) (FTV)
The Evil Clergyman (2012) (FTV)
Dazed and Confused (1993)
Ice Cream Man (1995)

All Through the House (2015) - Killer santa movie where a lot of dicks get chopped off.
Bad Santa (2003) - Decent Billy Bob drunken santa comedy with no moral or point.
Bad Santa 2 (2016) - More of the same, not as great this time around, but not terrible.
The Ref (1994) - Denis Leary robs people, and they all love him.
Santa with Muscles (1996) - Hulk Hogan stinker about jerk turned amnesiac Santa Claus. Childish drivel.
Santa's Slay (2005) - Goldberg plays an evil Santa warrior who kills the fuck out of everyone.
Silent Night, Deadly Night 3 (1989) - Flashback/filler shit sequel with nothing memorable.
Silent Night, Deadly Night 4 (1990) - More FX heavy Yuzna flick that still winds up kinda mediocre.
Silent Night, Deadly Night 5 (1991) - Kinda like the Halloween III of the bunch, cuz they have robots.

Dismembering Christmas (2015) - Rewatch - 3/10
Nobody Loves Alice (2008) - FTV - 6/10
To all A Goodnight (1980) - Rewatch - 4/10
August Underground's Pennance (2007) - Rewatch - 4/10
Dreaming Purple Neon (2016) - FTV - 7/10
Santa Claus Conquers The Martians (1964) - Rewatch - 5/10
Ernest Saves Christmas (1988) - Rewatch - 4/10
Silent Night Bloody Night (1972) - Rewatch - 5/10
Better Watch Out (2016) - FTV - 7/10
Curtains (1983) - Rewatch - 3/10
Devil Rider! (1970) - Rewatch - 4/10